Agenda item

SY Airport City

Decision:

RESOLVED that the Board is recommended to:-

1.    Note and consider the contents of this report including:

Appendix 1 - DSA Full Business Case

Appendix 2 - DSA Financial Viability Report

Appendix 3 - DSA Full Business Case Independent Assessment

Appendix 4 - DSA Business Case Review

Appendix 5 - Delivering the High Case Passenger Forecast

Appendix 6 - DSA Lease Advice

Appendix 7.1 - Gateway East - DSA Feasibility Report - Main Report

Appendix 7.2 - Gateway East - DSA Feasibility Report - Site Strategy Plan

Appendix 7.3 - Gateway East - DSA Feasibility Report - Planning Commentary

Appendix 7.4 - Gateway East - DSA Feasibility Report - Summary Constraints and Opportunities

Appendix 7.5 - Gateway East - DSA Feasibility Report - The Opportunity for Growth

Appendix 7.6 - Gateway East - DSA Feasibility Report - Feasibility Cost Model

Appendix 7.7 - Gateway East - DSA Feasibility Report - Gateway East Infrastructure Note

Appendix 8.1 - DSA BCR Review

Appendix 8.1 - DSA BCR Review - Assumption Impacts with BCR Changes

Appendix 9.1 - DSA Climate Impact Report

Appendix 9.2 - DSA Climate Impact Cost Report

Appendix 10 - DSA Sustainability Opportunity Statement

Appendix 11 - DSA & Gateway East Surface Access Statement

Appendix 12 - DSA Employment & Skills Assessment

Appendix 13 - SYAC Equality Impact Assessment

Appendix 14 - SYAC Governance Options

Appendix 15 - Proposed Conditions Precedent & Contractual Controls

Appendix 16.1 - Funding Summary Page 330

Appendix 16.2 - Financial Model Summary

Appendix 16.3 - Financial Modelling

Appendix 17 - SYAC Risk Report Update

2.    Subject to the entering into of a Funding Agreement as per recommendation 7, approve the funding commitment to CDC to facilitate the re-opening of DSA and operation at a total level of up-to £159.52m as detailed in paragraph 3.110 below and Appendix 16.1.

3.    Note that £121.62m of the funding required has been earmarked from Gainshare funding allocated to City of Doncaster Council’s (“CDC”) Place Investment Plan.

4.    Note that £30m of the funding required has been earmarked from funding committed to SYMCA’s 2026/27 Integrated Settlement.

5.    Note that £6m of the funding required has been earmarked from recycled Local Growth Fund loan funding.

6.    Note that it is proposed to re-deploy £1.9m Gainshare funding from a previously agreed Doncaster based project.

7.    Approve the MCA entering into a Funding Agreement with CDC on terms to be approved by the MCA Monitoring Officer in consultation with the Mayor and Chief Finance Officer that sets out the conditions precedent and contractual control measures detailed in paragraph 3.100 and Appendix 15.

8.    Approve the MCA being represented on the Board of Directors of Fly Doncaster Limited by two non-executive appointments nominated by the MCA Chief Executive.

9.    Delegate to the MCA Chief Executive in consultation with the Mayor, Chief Finance Officer and Monitoring Officer, authority to certify satisfaction of the conditions precedent by CDC required under the Funding Agreement.

Minutes:

The Chair advised that he was pleased to introduce the next agenda item, following the tireless efforts to reopen DSA and expressed his pride in reaching this point.

 

The Chair advised that the MCA and the City of Doncaster Council (CDC) had worked together on plans to reopen and redevelop the site. Key milestones included:

  • Acquisition of airport land and assets;
  • Regulatory steps to reinstate airspace;
  • Appointment of Munich International Airport (MIA) as consultants:
  • £16 million in MCA funding to support site costs, operational planning, and business case development.

 

A strategic vision had been established to position the reopened airport as a catalyst for South Yorkshire Airport City (SYAC) and wider economic growth in the region.

 

He invited Mayor Ros Jones to speak to the significance of the decision. She stated that this was a pivotal moment in the region’s development. It represented the largest single investment in Doncaster in more than a generation and a transformative opportunity for trade, exports, and growth.

 

The Chair welcomed the remaining three public questions. Michael Regan had submitted the following:

The Mayor announced an independent Inquiry into strategic infrastructure (1st Feb 2023). One direction was - “It should consider the case for reforms that would increase the influence of democratically elected representatives, including council Leaders and Mayors”.

November FOI response stated that the report would be published “no later than the 1st February 2025”. A further FOI (April 2025) responded publication delayed until, “discussions in relation to South Yorkshire Airport City are concluded”.

1.      Has the full report been provided to parties involved in investment discussions concerning the airport?

2.      When will the full report be made publicly available?

 

The Chair responded that the Inquiry had been established to review and propose reforms in the regulatory, policy, and legal framework governing the management of regional assets. Specifically, it was meant to prevent or mitigate scenarios like the closure of DSA. This was an important piece of work and would usually have been published by now. 

 

The terms of reference for the Inquiry made it clear that it should avoid any actions that could prejudice ongoing legal and commercial negotiations surrounding the DSA site. Therefore, the original timeline for the Inquiry and further updates on an intended publication date had been delayed to ensure that these aligned with the decision that would be taken at today's meeting. 

 

The timeline for the publication of the full report was under discussion with the independent Chair and remained in line with the criteria set out in the Inquiry’s Terms of Reference.

 

He acknowledged the significance of these concerns and provided assurance that the findings and recommendations of the report were intended to inform both national and regional approaches to major infrastructure assets. The goal was to ensure that future decisions regarding strategic regional assets like DSA were made with comprehensive stakeholder input and due consideration of their broader economic and community impacts.

 

The second question was from Wai Ming Yau:

Due diligence shows this airport is unaffordable in all base scenarios and only breaks even if the most optimistic freight and property forecasts are hit, while passengers remain a loss-maker reliant on public subsidy. Given there are no signed freight operators, no binding airline commitments, and a funding cap already stretched by inflation, can you explain to taxpayers why this isn’t simply a logistics property gamble dressed up as an airport revival, and what guarantees you can give that this won’t become an open-ended public subsidy sink?

 

The assurance review makes clear that the current business case does not yet satisfy HM Treasury’s Green Book standards or the Five Case Model. Only the Strategic Case would meet the guidelines, with the Financial and Commercial Case RAG rated Red, it is not affordable even in the high-case scenario. In light of this, will the board commit to introducing additional gateways or governance — with clear stop–go decision points linked to operator commitments, freight volumes, and regulatory milestones — before further public money is released? Furthermore, the head lease performance clause remains tied to passenger volumes, including a 2036 threshold that even the high-case forecasts fall short of, and at 1.926m, it is higher than any annual passenger traffic ever achieved in the airport’s 17-year operating history. Given that freight, rather than passengers, will ultimately determine the airport’s viability, will you commit to renegotiating this clause so that it is freight-focused and realistically achievable, rather than exposing the region to the risk of lease termination based on unattainable passenger targets?

 

The due diligence mentions an operator with demonstrable UK regional airport experience and strong pre-existing relationships with airlines and freight integrators. In light of those concerns, can the board confirm it is committed to Munich or is it actively considering a live workstream for a competitive search?

 

The Chair replied that following the assessment of the full business case the MCA had commissioned a number of additional pieces of work. This work included a review of the financial and business models, a more detailed sensitivity analysis of the economic case, work to test the market appetite for the proposal and a review of the lease conditionality. The additional work had gone into great depth over many months and supplemented the information received within the full business case. It had sought to mitigate as many of the risks as possible but with a project of this size and complexity, risk would remain. An informed decision could now be taken which balanced the risk alongside the opportunity.

 

He was unable to provide details relating to airlines or cargo operators as these were subject to ongoing commercial discussions. The landowner had engaged productively in renegotiating the lease thresholds with an in-principle agreement reached, such that risk would be sufficiently mitigated to proceed.

 

Throughout the additional assurance period he had considered options such as phased funding approvals, however, this approach could be counter-productive and reduce confidence in airlines to commit to operating from the airport.

 

MIA were appointed by Fly Doncaster and would continue to work with them to operationalise the airport. The report recommendations sought to confirm the overarching programme management function required to deliver such a complex programme of activity.

 

The final question had been received from Jenny Harrison:

In your papers, it says that airport operators walked away from the competition after looking at the lease. Does this suggest that the airport lease is too expensive?

 

Doncaster Sheffield Airport’s viability rests almost entirely on ambitious freight and property forecasts, not passengers, yet no freight operator has signed a binding agreement. How do you justify committing up to £159m of public money to an airport that could still operate at a loss for years if freight demand is slow to materialise, and what guarantees do you give that taxpayers won’t be left subsidising empty runways while we wait for a freight strategy that is still little more than an aspiration?"

 

Independent auditors have warned that passenger forecasts are optimistic, subsidies will be required to attract airlines, and even in the high case Doncaster will struggle to meet lease passenger targets. With Manchester, East Midlands, and Leeds Bradford all competing aggressively, how can you reassure the public that this isn’t just a political promise to restore flights that the market cannot support, and what is your threshold for walking away if passenger numbers flatline, rather than asking taxpayers to bankroll loss-making routes indefinitely in pursuit of an unrealistic vision?

 

In response, the Chair stated that he was unable to comment on the commercial reasons for potential airport operators not submitting bids. However, he could confirm that the lease had been renegotiated – in-principle - with the landowner. It was anticipated that this would reduce risks that could potentially dissuade private investment in the airport. 

 

In terms of targets for freight and property, as part of the additional assurance work that had been completed, specific advice had been sought from aviation experts to confirm that the revised targets for the airport were achievable. These estimates also included passenger numbers, which were a key part of the viability of the airport. These projections had specifically taken into account the potential impact of competition from neighbouring airports, such as Manchester, Leeds Bradford and East Midlands. 

 

Due to their commercially sensitive nature, it was not possible to talk about specific thresholds, however, it should be noted that comprehensive performance monitoring would be in place, which would provide the robust data to inform any future decision making. 

 

The Chair thanked all of the members of the public for their questions and committed to maintaining an open and transparent dialogue throughout this process.

 

The Executive Director of Resources & Investment outlined the extensive assurance work which had been undertaken, including the testing of traffic forecasts, financial models, lease risks, and the feasibility of Gateway East as an advanced industry hub. In addition, climate impacts, transport connectivity, skills, and inequality were also assessed.

 

The findings showed strong alignment with regional growth plans and confirmed the project’s technical feasibility and market interest. It had been confirmed that financial viability would be achievable under high traffic scenarios, with mitigations in place for key risks. Surface access and lease issues remained challenging, but solutions were being developed.

 

A number of residual critical risks were outlined, including ongoing resolution of the lease issues, the risk of a legal challenge associated with public subsidy, and the regulatory process for the return of airspace. These critical risks sit alongside inherent commercial and operational risks.

 

The report concluded that despite some optimistic initial estimates, the project still offered good value for money. It was therefore recommended that the project and funding be approved subject to conditions and controls presented in the appendices.

 

The Chair expressed his intention to vote in favour of reopening DSA, citing three years of engagement and careful consideration of both risks and opportunities. He emphasised the need to balance responsible use of public funds with the potential to create significant opportunities for South Yorkshire. He also saw the project as a chance to improve quality of life across the region. He acknowledged the risks, but felt the long-term benefits justified support.

 

The Chair then requested that the other Members of the Board share their views and voting intentions.

 

Cllr Sir Steve Houghton expressed Barnsley’s support for reopening DSA, and noted that all concerns raised in prior meetings, particularly around financial impact, lease risks, and forecast usage, had been satisfactorily addressed. He highlighted the substantial potential economic benefits for South Yorkshire including for Barnsley.

 

Cllr Chris Read confirmed his intention to vote in favour of the airport reopening. He stated that his questions had been answered during the thorough discussion and assurance over several months. He emphasised the airport’s potential to drive jobs and economic growth across South Yorkshire, beyond just Doncaster. He considered the decision would be a major step forward for the region’s future.

 

Cllr Tom Hunt endorsed the reopening of DSA. He recognised its potential to boost jobs and economic growth across South Yorkshire. He emphasised the need for sustainability and early adoption of clean aviation technologies and renewable energy. He supported the project as an opportunity for regional prosperity.

 

Members also commended Mayor Ros Jones for her unwavering commitment to the project.

 

RESOLVED UNANIMOUSLY that the Board:

1.      Note and consider the contents of this report including:

Appendix 1 - DSA Full Business Case

Appendix 2 - DSA Financial Viability Report

Appendix 3 - DSA Full Business Case Independent Assessment

Appendix 4 - DSA Business Case Review

Appendix 5 - Delivering the High Case Passenger Forecast

Appendix 6 - DSA Lease Advice

Appendix 7.1 - Gateway East - DSA Feasibility Report - Main Report

Appendix 7.2 - Gateway East - DSA Feasibility Report - Site Strategy Plan

Appendix 7.3 - Gateway East - DSA Feasibility Report - Planning Commentary

Appendix 7.4 - Gateway East - DSA Feasibility Report - Summary Constraints and Opportunities

Appendix 7.5 - Gateway East - DSA Feasibility Report - The Opportunity for Growth

Appendix 7.6 - Gateway East - DSA Feasibility Report - Feasibility Cost Model

Appendix 7.7 - Gateway East - DSA Feasibility Report - Gateway East Infrastructure Note

Appendix 8.1 - DSA BCR Review

Appendix 8.1 - DSA BCR Review - Assumption Impacts with BCR Changes

Appendix 9.1 - DSA Climate Impact Report

Appendix 9.2 - DSA Climate Impact Cost Report

Appendix 10 - DSA Sustainability Opportunity Statement

Appendix 11 - DSA & Gateway East Surface Access Statement

Appendix 12 - DSA Employment & Skills Assessment

Appendix 13 - SYAC Equality Impact Assessment

Appendix 14 - SYAC Governance Options

Appendix 15 - Proposed Conditions Precedent & Contractual Controls

Appendix 16.1 - Funding Summary

Appendix 16.2 - Financial Model Summary

Appendix 16.3 - Financial Modelling

Appendix 17 - SYAC Risk Report Update

2.      Subject to the entering into of a Funding Agreement as per recommendation 7, approve the funding commitment to CDC to facilitate the re-opening of DSA and operation at a total level of up-to £159.52m as detailed in paragraph 3.110 below and Appendix 16.1.

3.      Note that £121.62m of the funding required has been earmarked from Gainshare funding allocated to City of Doncaster Council’s (“CDC”) Place Investment Plan.

4.      Note that £30m of the funding required has been earmarked from funding committed to SYMCA’s 2026/27 Integrated Settlement.

5.      Note that £6m of the funding required has been earmarked from recycled Local Growth Fund loan funding.

6.      Note that it is proposed to re-deploy £1.9m Gainshare funding from a previously agreed Doncaster based project.

7.      Approve the MCA entering into a Funding Agreement with CDC on terms to be approved by the MCA Monitoring Officer in consultation with the Mayor and Chief Finance Officer that sets out the conditions precedent and contractual control measures detailed in paragraph 3.100 and Appendix 15.

8.      Approve the MCA being represented on the Board of Directors of Fly Doncaster Limited by two non-executive appointments nominated by the MCA Chief Executive.

9.      Delegate to the MCA Chief Executive in consultation with the Mayor, Chief Finance Officer and Monitoring Officer, authority to certify satisfaction of the conditions precedent by CDC required under the Funding Agreement.

Supporting documents: